Menu
Click Here To Call Now

Pittsburgh: 412-906-8102

Toll Free: 800-440-5297

Senators Santorum and Frist deceptive in urging medical malpractice reform, ATLA accuses.

In spite of the United States Senate's recent rejection of proposed medical malpractice reform, Senators Rick Santorum and Bill Frist were recently in Scranton again urging such reform. The American Trial Lawyers Association, whose stated goals are promoting justice for injured persons, defending the right to jury trials, and strengthening the civil justice system by disclosing information critical to public health and safety, issued a statement accusing the two senators of hypocrisy and deception.

After stating that the senators' real reason for urging reform was to obtain campaign contributions, primarily from the insurance industry, the press release noted that Santorum was attempting to curb the rights of Pennsylvanians despite the fact that his wife had successfully sued her chiropractor for medical malpractice. ATLA also accused the pair of ignoring mounting evidence that malpractice insurance rates were rising because of price gouging by the insurance industry and not by lawsuits filed injured patients. (The statement noted that an insurance firm controlled by the Frist family was one of the most blatant price gougers.) ATLA noted a study by the Institute of Medicine that between 44,000 and 98,000 citizens die each year from medical negligence.

ATLA accused Santorum and Frist of ignoring various data and studies that showed that the justifications for medical malpractice reform could not withstand critical scrutiny. With regard to the claim that numerous lawsuits were driving up costs, the "reformers" ignored statistics release by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court that the number of medical malpractice cases filed had dropped 35% between 2000 (2632 filings) and 2005 (1698 filings). In fact, those statistics also showed that in Lackawanna County, where the pair had appeared, filings dropped 50% over that same period (71 to 35).

It is often claimed that reform is needed because Americans and Pennsylvanians are being denied access to health care. This claim, however, is refuted by a 2003 study of the Government Accountability Office that found "many of the reported provider actions taken in response to malpractice pressures were not substantiated or did not widely affect access to health care...."

ATLA'a main claim that Santorum and Frist were being dishonest was with regard to their assertion that their proposed reform would reduce malpractice insurance costs. The press release noted a number of different matters. First, a 2005 study by Public Citizen showed that the number a medical malpractice payments of behalf of physicians fell by 13% between 2001 and 2004 and that adjusted for inflation, average malpractice payments had increased less that 2% a year between 1991 and 2004. Second, a 2005 study by the Missouri insurance commissioner found that the 15 largest medical malpractice insurers had increased premiums between 2001 and 2004 by 120% in spite of the fact that payouts had increased by less than 6%. Incredibly, the insurer controlled by the Frist family had increased its premiums by 88% between 2000 and 2004 despite a corresponding 32% drop in claim payments. Finally, ATLA noted a number of statements from insurance industry executives that the proposed reform would not lead to a reduction insurance premiums.

Sources: ATLA, Public Citizen, Government Accountability Office, Institute of Medicine

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
How can We Help?

How Can We Help? Contact Our Office Today At 800-440-5297 Or Fill Out The Form Below.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information
disclaimer.

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

close

Privacy Policy

Rosen Louik & Perry, P.C.
437 Grant Street Suite 200, The Frick Building
Pittsburgh, PA 15219

Phone: 412-281-4200
Fax: 412-281-2997
Pittsburgh Law Office Map

There is NO FEE unless recovery is made.

Rosen Louik Perry, P.C. Pittsburgh
412-906-8102 CaringLawyers.com 1-800-243-5297